Photo credit: NHL
Fan suggests that Habs forward is actually better than Auston Matthews

Fan suggests that Habs forward is actually better than Auston Matthews

BY RYAN SMITHERAM    AUGUST 26, 2023  (5:58 PM)
After Auston Matthews signed a 4-year extension that will see him earn $13.25M per season with the Leafs beginning in the 2024-25 season, social media went crazy with fans from other markets suggesting that the Matthews extension is far too rich for the most random reasons. One Habs fan took things to another level saying that Cole Caufield's new extension is better than Matthews'.


Caufield signed an 8-year deal last season that will see him earn $7.8M per season. The Habs fan suggested that Caufield is the superior player because he and the Habs have 3 playoff series wins to Matthews' 1 with the Leafs.

In Caufield's entry-level contract, he put up a total of 53 goals and 84 points in 123 games. In comparison, Matthews put up 111 goals and 205 points in 212 games. Yes, Matthews played more games but he had more goals in his first 3 seasons than Caufield had points and it wasn't even close.


This comparison might be one of the most obnoxious comparisons I've ever witnessed. Leave it to a Habs fan, though, to create that kind of baseless comparison.
WOULD YOU RATHER HAVE 1 AUSTON MATTHEWS OR 2 COLE CAUFIELDS?
AUGUST 26      864 ANSWERS
1 AUSTON MATTHEWS53261.6 %
2 COLE CAUFIELDS33238.4 %
  LIST OF POLLS
1 HOUR AGO
Robertson touches on injury problems, how he's feeling in camp

Robertson touches on injury problems, how he's feeling in camp

BY MIKE ARMENTI
Leafs prospect Nick Robertson spoke this week about his injury problems and where he's at now, mentally and physically. More here
2 HOURS AGO
Vasilevskiy attempting to cause problems for video review teams

Vasilevskiy attempting to cause problems for video review teams

BY MIKE ARMENTI
Lightning netminder Andrei Vasilevskiy makes equipment change in hopes of interfering with video review. Details inside
7 HOURS AGO
Ryan Reaves likely to hit waivers over the next few weeks

Ryan Reaves likely to hit waivers over the next few weeks

BY BEN HODGSON
Brad Treliving's first move as GM was signing one of the league's last true enforcers in Ryan Reaves. Now Reaves is likely waiver bound. Find out why here
8 HOURS AGO
Insider reveals how close the Leafs were to acquiring Stamkos

Insider reveals how close the Leafs were to acquiring Stamkos

BY MIKE ARMENTI
Elliotte Friedman dropped a bombshell on the most recent 32 Thoughts, revealing that the Leafs came very close to actually landing Steven Stamkos. Details here
pub
FOLLOW US
facebookinstagram
252 174 followers
8 HOURS AGO
Bertuzzi, Marner already developing excellent chemistry at camp

Bertuzzi, Marner already developing excellent chemistry at camp

BY MIKE ARMENTI
Marner and Bertuzzi are already developing some solid chemistry with one another in training camp, as is evidenced by this clip. Watch here
8 HOURS AGO
Lightning reportedly fine with losing their captain

Lightning reportedly fine with losing their captain

BY RYAN SMITHERAM
Elliotte Friedman has suggested that Steven Stamkos and the Lightning may be preparing to part ways. Details here
9 HOURS AGO
Line brawl started by Leafs development camp invitee

Line brawl started by Leafs development camp invitee

BY RYAN SMITHERAM
Watch here as Leaf development camp invitee starts a line brawl in OHL pre-season game
9 HOURS AGO
Robertson absolutely snipes a pair of goals; looks good in camp

Robertson absolutely snipes a pair of goals; looks good in camp

BY MIKE ARMENTI
Robertson shows that his shoulder injury is behind him, wiring two pucks bar down with a pair of sick goals. Watch here
LEADERS
2022-2023
GPGAPTS
1-  
CONNOR MCDAVID
826489153
2-  
LEON DRAISAITL
805276128
3-  
DAVID PASTRNAK
826152113
4-  
NIKITA KUCHEROV
823083113
5-  
NATHAN MACKINNON
714269111
6-  
MATTHEW TKACHUK
794069109
7-  
JASON ROBERTSON
824663109
8-  
MIKKO RANTANEN
825550105
9-  
RYAN NUGENT-HOPKINS
823767104
10-  
ELIAS PETTERSSON
803963102
2022-2023 LEADERS  
10 HOURS AGO
New Leafs setting new tone in battle drills on day one of camp

New Leafs setting new tone in battle drills on day one of camp

BY RYAN SMITHERAM
Ryan Reaves and Max Domi setting the tone early at Leafs training camp during 1-on-1 battle drills
11 HOURS AGO
Leafs GM reveals why he signed only one single PTO this offseason

Leafs GM reveals why he signed only one single PTO this offseason

BY DEAN CHAUDHRY
Treliving offered just one single PTO this offseason, but his rationale behind the decision is actually very cool. Details here
12 HOURS AGO
Leafs head coach reveals Nylander's new linemates

Leafs head coach reveals Nylander's new linemates

BY RYAN SMITHERAM
Find out here what Leafs head coach Sheldon Keefe had to say about Nylander and his new linemates
SEP 21
Martin Jones honouring iconic Leafs goaltenders on his new mask

Martin Jones honouring iconic Leafs goaltenders on his new mask

BY DEAN CHAUDHRY
Martin Jones' new Leafs mask honours some of the greatest goaltenders in Maple Leafs franchise history. See it here
SEP 21
Samsonov touches on his relationship with GM after arbitration

Samsonov touches on his relationship with GM after arbitration

BY RYAN SMITHERAM
Find out here what Samsonov had to say about his relationship with Treliving following arbitration
SEP 21
Nylander refuses to talk about his contract status

Nylander refuses to talk about his contract status

BY MIKE ARMENTI
After months of discussion about his contract status, William Nylander stated today that he won't take questions on it after today. More info here
SEP 21
Bertuzzi draws top line assignment, comments on the honour

Bertuzzi draws top line assignment, comments on the honour

BY MIKE ARMENTI
Bertuzzi draws top line assignment on day one of training camp, skating alongside Matthews and Marner. Find out here what he had to say following his first session
SEP 21
Former Leaf vocal about not liking Nylander at center

Former Leaf vocal about not liking Nylander at center

BY RYAN SMITHERAM
One former Maple Leaf and current analyst understands trying Nylander on the wing, but doesn't believe it will work out. Details here
SEP 21
Matthews taking on new role with Leafs this season

Matthews taking on new role with Leafs this season

BY RYAN SMITHERAM
Find out here what Sheldon Keefe's next challenge is for Auston Matthews
SEP 21
Kane spotted in Toronto, leading to more rumours

Kane spotted in Toronto, leading to more rumours

BY RYAN SMITHERAM
Kane spotted in Toronto as he continues to take steps toward a return to action. Details here
SEP 21
Injury delays the start of one new Leaf's training camp

Injury delays the start of one new Leaf's training camp

BY MIKE ARMENTI
Newly-signed Maple Leaf misses the first day of on-ice sessions at training camp with an injury. Details here
SEP 21
Two ex-Leafs land PTOs just before training camps open

Two ex-Leafs land PTOs just before training camps open

BY MIKE ARMENTI
Two ex-Maple Leafs not leaving anything to chance, sign PTOs before training camps open up. Details here
SEP 21
Lightning and captain Steven Stamkos headed towards a split?

Lightning and captain Steven Stamkos headed towards a split?

BY DEAN CHAUDHRY
The Lightning have handed out extensions to several young players. Stamkos has yet to receive his and some think there will be a new chapter in Tampa without Stamkos
SEP 21
Tkachuk clowns on the Bruins; Sharks D-man watching the Leafs

Tkachuk clowns on the Bruins; Sharks D-man watching the Leafs

BY DEAN CHAUDHRY
Matthew Tkachuk clowns on the Bruins and a Sharks defenseman will have his eyes on the Leafs this season. More here
SEP 20
Find out which Leafs players added significant size this summer

Find out which Leafs players added significant size this summer

BY DEAN CHAUDHRY
Heading into the 2023-24 season, the Leafs aren't messing around when it comes to size, snarl, and snot. Several Leafs have bulked up a lot this summer. More here
SEP 20
Analyst believes Nylander will raise his value this season

Analyst believes Nylander will raise his value this season

BY RYAN SMITHERAM
Find out here what Jamie McLeannan thinks of the Nylander situation in Toronto
SEP 20
Leafs experimenting with William Nylander's position at camp

Leafs experimenting with William Nylander's position at camp

BY BEN HODGSON
Since joining the Maple Leafs, William Nylander has played primarily on the wing. That's no longer the case, per Sheldon Keefe. More here
SEP 20
Leafs coach says underdog has a legit shot to play in the top six

Leafs coach says underdog has a legit shot to play in the top six

BY MIKE ARMENTI
Leafs head coach Sheldon Keefe reveals that there will be a legitimate underdog challenger for a top-6 spot. More info here
SEP 20
Leafs GM Brad Treliving provides important Jake Muzzin update

Leafs GM Brad Treliving provides important Jake Muzzin update

BY RYAN SMITHERAM
As training camp officially opens, the Leafs provided a significant update regarding the injured Jake Muzzin. Details here
SEP 20
Major update regarding Maple Leafs goaltender Matt Murray

Major update regarding Maple Leafs goaltender Matt Murray

BY RYAN SMITHERAM
Leafs GM drops major update on injured Leafs goaltender Matt Murray. Details inside
SEP 20
Marner responds to media question about Babcock saga

Marner responds to media question about Babcock saga

BY MIKE ARMENTI
Marner, Tavares among those who have taken the high road in the Mike Babcock saga. Details here
SEP 20
Leafs plan to play a lot heavier than we've seen in the past

Leafs plan to play a lot heavier than we've seen in the past

BY MIKE ARMENTI
Leafs preparing to be a lot more physical this season, according to captain John Tavares. Details here
SEP 20
Matthews expresses excitement over Reaves, Domi, Bertuzzi deals

Matthews expresses excitement over Reaves, Domi, Bertuzzi deals

BY MIKE ARMENTI
Auston Matthews met with the media on Wednesday and dropped a sensational quote regarding a trio of new Maple Leafs additions. Details here
SEP 20
Maple Leafs Training Camp roster reavealed

Maple Leafs Training Camp roster reavealed

BY MIKE ARMENTI
Leafs unveil their 67-player training camp roster. See inside for more information
SEP 20
Friedman provides Nylander update as training camp opens

Friedman provides Nylander update as training camp opens

BY RYAN SMITHERAM
Insider provides update on Nylander and his ongoing contract negotiations as training camp opens on the 2023-24 campaign. More info here
SEP 19
Former Leaf reportedly the one who exposed Babcock

Former Leaf reportedly the one who exposed Babcock

BY RYAN SMITHERAM
Bissonnette and Whitney explain how their information was provided to them about Babcock. It came from a former Leaf. Details here
SEP 19
Additional disturbing Mike Babcock allegations emerge

Additional disturbing Mike Babcock allegations emerge

BY DEAN CHAUDHRY
More information continues to leak out about Babcock like how he initiated meetings at his house, not just in his office. Details inside
SEP 19
Podcast identifies Nylander as 5th best player from 2014 draft

Podcast identifies Nylander as 5th best player from 2014 draft

BY MIKE ARMENTI
If the Islanders had drafted Nylander at 5th overall back in 2014, here's who the Leafs may have ended up with. Details inside
SEP 19
Comparing the Leafs blueline Dubas inherited to Treliving's group

Comparing the Leafs blueline Dubas inherited to Treliving's group

BY RYAN SMITHERAM
Treliving's blueline in Toronto is in a much better place than Kyle Dubas' group was when he took over in 2018. Here's a comparison
SEP 19
Spittin' Chiclets issues warning to anyone mistreating players

Spittin' Chiclets issues warning to anyone mistreating players

BY BEN HODGSON
Paul Bissonnette has made it perfectly clear that any coach mistreating a player like Mike Babcock did will suffer the same fate. Watch the clip here
SEP 19
Leafs prospects exceeding expectations, developing nicely

Leafs prospects exceeding expectations, developing nicely

BY MIKE ARMENTI
Three Maple Leafs prospects developing, improving much quicker than expected. See the most recent projections here
SEP 19
Veteran forward wants to play 18th season, but won't sign PTO

Veteran forward wants to play 18th season, but won't sign PTO

BY MIKE ARMENTI
Insider reveals that a 37-year-old veteran pivot wants to return for an 18th season, but won't sign a PTO to make it happen. Details here
SEP 19
Knies, Nylander share funny Family Guy skit at Leafs Golf Classic

Knies, Nylander share funny Family Guy skit at Leafs Golf Classic

BY RYAN SMITHERAM
Knies and Nylander perform a hilarious Family Guy skit at Leafs Golf Classic; Watch here
SEP 19
Important details about Leafs training camp released

Important details about Leafs training camp released

BY BEN HODGSON
With the Traverse City tournament out of the way, Leafs training camp info has been released. Details here
SEP 19
Sens forward appears to take a shot at Leafs' top players

Sens forward appears to take a shot at Leafs' top players

BY RYAN SMITHERAM
Find out here what Sens forward Stutzle had to say about his contract; did he fire a shot at the Leafs? It seems as though he did. More here
SEP 18
Max Domi responds to questions from the Toronto media

Max Domi responds to questions from the Toronto media

BY DEAN CHAUDHRY
Max Domi discusses all things Leafs during media session in Toronto. He discusses why he chose Toronto, where he'll play and some comments from his time in Montreal