Insider discusses the latest on the Sheldon Keefe situation in Toronto

Published May 27, 2023 at 9:38
BY MIKE ARMENTI

With all of the focus in Toronto currently on the ongoing search for a general manager, some of the other important storylines have taken a back seat, or have been swept under the rug for the time being. One of those storylines involves head coach Sheldon Keefe and whether or not he'll be back with the team next season.

As far as the lead-up to Brendan Shanahan's dismissal of Kyle Dubas late last week, there was a strong belief in some circles that Keefe would not be back. In fact, we had a source share some pretty convincing information surrounding Keefe being on the cusp of being relieved of his duties as head coach ahead of the final year of his deal. However, with Dubas being let go by the organization, it sort of put everything else on hold - including some ongoing discussions with Luke Schenn on a contract extension in Toronto, as Schenn pointed out yesterday.

TSN's Darren Dreger discussed the topic of Keefe's future in Toronto yesterday on TSN1050's First Up and had stated that there's certainly a chance now that Keefe could return for the final season on his contract, but also stated that the decision has to be made by the new GM. This falls in line with what Brendan Shanahan had said during his press conference last week. Shanahan had not mentioned Keefe by name even once and when asked about Keefe's future in Toronto, Shanahan deflected, pivoting to the fact that the team's GM will be involved in that decision, as would AGM Brandon Pridham.

"I would think that, for the GM coming in, unless he just believes - in conversation with Shanahan and your star players - that a coaching change is needed, I'm not so sure why there would be an urgency to make that change because we know that there are other candidates that are out there. Andrew Brunette is going to be an NHL head coach next season. Travis Green is back in the conversation, as he should be. Where is Gerard Gallant going to land?.. so there are candidates - for sure there are. If you want to go down the path of experience, Peter Laviolette for me makes a lot of sense, but again, are we selling Sheldon short here? Did he flat out get out-coached by the Florida Panthers [and the] experience of Paul Maurice? Some would say yes he did... I don't like pinning things on head coaches.. I put it on the players, to be fair." - Dreger on whether or not the Leafs will replace Sheldon Keefe this summer



As we well know, typically a GM likes to have his own coach. If the Leafs truly are looking at Brad Treliving as their front-runner, Dreger wonders whether that has played into why Keefe has not yet been let go by the team. As we well know, Treliving doesn't really have "a guy" right now. We know how things ended in Calgary with Treliving and Darryl Sutter, so Dreger really doesn't think Sutter would be a guy that he'd look to reunite with in Toronto.

Naturally, everything is in a bit of a holding pattern right now, but in terms of where the club is at with Keefe, it's pretty safe to say that the Leafs' split with Kyle Dubas changed everything, at least for the time being. Unfortunately, we likely won't have a better idea of which side of what's coming until a new GM is named.

POLL
May 27   |   530 answers
Insider discusses the latest on the Sheldon Keefe situation in Toronto

Will Sheldon Keefe be the coach of this Leafs team next season?

No26750.4 %
Yes10820.4 %
It would be a mistake to keep him10820.4 %
It would be a mistake to fire him478.9 %
LIST OF POLL
Latest 10 stories